Cooling: Scythe Kamakaze Review :: Conclusion

Author: Tolemac · 02-10-2004 · Category: Hardware - Cooling
Motherboards.org Editor's Choice Winner

Now that you've picked your jaws up off the floor, go back and LOOK AT THOSE SCORES AGAIN!

To say that I am completely blown away is an understatement. I truly never expected another air-cooled heatsink to out-perform the MCX-462. Not only did the Kamakaze do that, it did it in every test but one. Since finishing up testing, I've thrown every CPU intensive program and game that I have at it and they all ran flawlessly while overclocked. So I did what I hadn't been able to do till now. I increased the overclock. As I write this, my little 1.47GHz XP1700+ is now running at 2.20GHz! An additional increase of another 100MHz above the old overclock, and not one hic-up! What's the CPU temperature right now, you ask? With a couple of browsers, Outlook and Word going, it is 31.8°C at full fan speed. And that's another thing. While the fan is rated at 37dBA at full throttle, I'm here to tell you that there is no way it is that loud. I can hear the heatsink fan just above the case fans and they are on low. It does not produce a whine or high pitch noise at any speed.

Ok, so despite the amazing cooling performance shown here, not everything is all skittles and beer. I feel that the clamping mechanism, while going in the right direction, needs to be re-worked so that there is no chance of CPU damage when installing. Also, a fan guard MUST be included for protection. Finally, the instructions need to be a lot clearer. Outside of those three items, this is my new favorite heatsink, and it has found a home on my now "uber overclocked" system. Coming in at a street price of around $34.95, this is a very affordable heatsink. If this is the type of performance we can expect from Scythe, then I eagerly look forward to their next products! I am extremely pleased to give the Kamakaze my heartiest recommendation and an Editor's Choice Award!

You can check out their other items at www.scythe-usa.com or at www.scythe.co.jp.

Till next time, Stay Cool!

Pros:

  • Excellent cooling performance!
  • Adjustable fan switch
  • Adaptable for either AMD or Intel systems
  • Very well machined
  • Very low fan noise at all speeds
  • Great overall heatsink design
  • Very good fan shroud design

Cons:

  • Clamping design needs to be reworked
  • No fan guard
  • Instructions could be clearer
Asus P5Q LGA775 ATX Motherboard
Intel D945GCLF Desktop Board
MSI Computer K9N6PGM2-V MICRO-ATX Motherboard
Intel DP45SG LGA775 ATX Motherboard
Asrock ALIVENF6P-VSTA Micro ATX AMD Motherboard
XFX Force Geforce 750A SLI MCP AM2+ Motherboard
Gigabyte GA-EX58-UD3R ATX Desktop Motherboard
Asus Rampage II Extreme Intel X58 Chipset Motherboard
Asus P5Q-E Intel P45 Core 2 QUAD/CORE 2 Extreme Motherboard
HP 360427-001 Compaq System Motherboard